Siesta Key Seafood Restaurant Captain Curt’s

Captain Curt’s Siesta Key Seafood Restaurant

Captain Curt’s Crab & Oyster Bar is one of the best siesta key seafood restaurants along the Florida Gulf. When you’re in the Sarasota area looking for fresh fish, tasty appetizers, and mouthwatering entrees, Captain Curt’s is your go-to option. First, the food is fantastic, and we offer a blend of freshly caught Gulf fish, fried seafood, and non-seafood items. Our cocktail menu is extensive, so be sure to have a drink or two while you eat. We’re also very family-friendly, with dishes that cater to everyone of any age. We host live music on most nights too, providing extra entertainment with your meal. Overall, if you want a fantastic dining experience, come to Captain Curt’s Crab & Oyster Bar.

Try the Best Seafood in Siesta Key

Why is Captain Curt’s  Crab & Oyster Bar one of the best restaurants in Siesta Key? It’s simple—we put food and customers first, ensuring we deliver the best dining experience possible. Whether you’re here for brunch, lunch, or dinner, you’re sure to leave happy and satisfied.

We also cater to everyone. Families love us because of our fun and friendly ambiance, as well as kid-friendly menu items. Couples love us because of our extensive collection of craft beers and signature cocktails. Seafood lovers flock to our restaurant because we’re the top Siesta Key oyster bar and restaurant. We have the best seafood from the Gulf and beyond and are proud of it!

Overall, Captain Curt’s is more than just a seafood restaurant. We’re also the best Siesta Key tiki bar, coffee shop, and live music venue in the area. No matter your mood, we’re here for you!

Captain Curt’s: the Best Siesta Key Seafood Restaurants

Because Siesta Key is on the water, it’s easy to find local seafood. Best of all, Captain Curt’s  Crab & Oyster Bar is the restaurant that ticks off all the boxes, including:

  • Comfortable Outdoor Dining – Florida weather is often balmy and relaxing, and our seating allows you and your group to sit in the sun without getting burned or bothered by bugs.
  • Casual, Family-Friendly Atmosphere – Often, a casual dining experience is best when you’re on vacation so you can relax after a long day on the beach. Captain Curt’s has a laid-back vibe that welcomes everyone.
  • Live Music and Entertainment – When you’re ready to hang out and have a great time, live music adds to the ambiance. This way, you can get some entertainment with your main course.
  • Affordable Prices – Just because you’re eating the best local seafood doesn’t mean it should cost an arm and a leg. So, finding a place that offers great food at an affordable price can often be a dealbreaker. Even better, we have a robust happy hour with many food and beer options.

Seafood lovers don’t have to scour through the entire Siesta Key village to find something that everyone can enjoy. Captain Curt’s blends all the quality of a seafood market with the fun atmosphere of an Old Florida tiki bar.

Captain Curt’s: Why We Have the Best Seafood Siesta Key

One of the main reasons to visit Siesta Key is to enjoy the best seafood restaurants. Fortunately, Captain Curt’s Crab & Oyster Bar is one of the best because we pay attention to what matters. Specifically:

  • Freshness – No one wants to eat old, chewy, or soggy seafood. We don’t shy away from featuring freshly caught fish to steamed crab legs and fresh oysters. However, we also offer fried seafood if you like a little extra crunch with your meal.
  • Variety – You’ll be amazed by how many different dishes we offer on the menu. From mouthwatering ribs to a fantastic grouper sandwich, there’s something for everyone to enjoy.
  • Service – Although great food counts greatly, the service must also match. We have some of the best waitstaff in Siesta Key, who are always willing to go the extra mile to ensure you get an incredible dining experience.

Types of Seafood Served

When going to other seafood restaurants, you often have to choose one type of food, such as a lobster pot, sandwiches, or fried entrees. Captain Curt’s  Crab & Oyster Bar gives you so many options that you don’t feel limited. Some of the top items on the menu include:

  • Clam Chowder – It’s safe to say that our clam chowder put us on the map! With thick chunks of potatoes, clams, and rich seasonings, you’ll be coming back for more. Our chowder is so popular that people often buy our kit to make it at home.
  • Fresh Fish – Whether you’re a fan of grouper, mahi mahi, or other white fish, you can get fillets, fish tacos, sandwiches, and more. If you’re really adventurous, you can always sample the catch of the day, which is about as fresh as you can get.
  • Shellfish – Do you love shrimp? Can you eat pounds of it in one sitting? What about crabs, mussels, oysters, and scallops? Captain Curt’s has it all! Stone crab legs, fresh oysters, mussel soup, and fried or peel-and-eat shrimp. You can also get the flakiest crab cakes on the island.

If, for some reason, you’re coming to Captain Curt’s for a seafood-less meal, we still have you covered. We offer other options like ribs, burgers, salads, and more. So, bring your family and friends as everyone can find something they’ll love.

Get the Freshest Seafood in Siesta Key at Captain Curt’s Crab & Oyster Bar

When it comes to good times, excellent food, and a lively atmosphere, Captain Curt’s Crab & Oyster Bar is the best option in Siesta Key. We invite you to sample our fresh fish, crabs, oysters, shrimp, and more! We’re also highly rated as a Siesta Key coffee shop if you need a pick-me-up with your meal. We’ll see you on the key!


A landmark restaurant on South Siesta Key in Sarasota, FL, since 1979, Captain Curt’s is more than a great seafood restaurant in Siesta Key with the World’s Best Clam Chowder. The casual family fun atmosphere, full outdoor tropical Tiki bar, and indoor and outdoor dining attract visitors & locals from around the world. Our restaurant is known for casual dining, delicious fresh local seafood, crab, oysters, sandwiches, lunch, and dinner.

Enjoy live music, try our real fruit daiquiris, daiquiris to go, tropical drinks, and local craft beer selections. Everyone will have a great time at Captain Curt’s family-friendly restaurant. Enjoy our seafood, oyster bar, bar, daiquiris, live music events and entertainment, coffee shop, and souvenir shopping at the souvenir and gift shop.

Captain Curt’s is committed to the customer experience. More than just dining, more than just a bar. We strive to ensure that every customer enjoys and remembers the time they spent there more than just the product they’ve purchased. The memories and the experience are what set us apart.

1200 Old Stickney Point Rd,
Sarasota, Florida, 34242

Directions »